Tiny, outdated, and ugly; which would be tolerable. But then they lied about the rate!! When I made my reservation I was told a certain rate for both nights. Now they are charging me that rate Per Night! When I spoke to Sandip, the manager, he was alternatively irate, smug, and belittling, and had no interest in what I had to say. Beware the Pegasus Hotel!

We recently stayed at the Pegasus and thought it was a great. Outdated decor in the room but it was very, very clean and you just can't beat the location. Plus, the rooftop pool/hot tub is a nice bonus and the free parking just down the street was a nice extra. Lastly, the price there was significantly cheaper than other Key West accommodations on Duval Street.

Great location.....that's the only positive comment that I can make. The room had that musty/moldy smell that won't go away. The carpet was damp - probably explains the smell issue. The night clerk brought a crank handle to open the windows and can of stuff to cover the smell. The day clerk did not respond in any way to our comments. Indicates to me that she was used to hearing complaints.

I would not return to this hotel. Ever.

We went to wedding in KW we booked 10 rooms. Why else do you go to the keys? To party. All you do in a hotel is sleep! Awesome Awesome location right on corner of Duval, walking distance to all hot spots, balcony overlooks Duval street. 24 hour pizza place right next door. I say for the money it wasn't bad. I read all other reviews and wonder whats wrong with these other people? The only thing I had a problem with was that the carpet seemed a bit too cool..maybe even damp. Otherwise for the money and location I say it was a cool deal. We stayed for four days. GOTTA get some pizza.